Normanville Pontoon vs Tennis Court Funding
Why consistency and transparency in decision-making matter.
Council Affairs — Commentary
Published 11 May 2026
The inconsistency
I am struggling to understand the inconsistency in how two comparable community projects have been treated.
The Normanville Pontoon
The Normanville Pontoon project had a budget allocation of $10,000, received over $9,000 in public donations, and demonstrated clear and undeniable community support, with more than 50 people in attendance at the gallery.
Despite this, the process was ultimately disregarded and, rather than progressing as expected, the matter was effectively overturned. The elected member body then required additional public funds to proceed with the pontoon, despite the strong financial and community backing already in place.
The Normanville Tennis Courts
In contrast, a $20,000 resurfacing cost for the Normanville Tennis Courts — also a valuable and important council asset — was passed unanimously without objection or significant scrutiny.
The disparity
Both projects are equally important to the community and both relate to council-owned infrastructure. However, the disparity in how they were assessed, debated, and approved raises serious concerns about transparency, consistency, and fairness in decision-making processes.
- !One project had $10,000 budgeted plus $9,000 in public donations — and was overturned
- !The other cost $20,000 from public funds — and passed without resistance
- !Both are council-owned community assets
The question
When a project with clear community backing, substantial fundraising, and an established budget allocation is treated so differently from another project that proceeds without resistance, it is difficult to reconcile how these outcomes are justified.
What the community deserves
At the very least, the community deserves a clear explanation of why the processes appeared to be applied so differently, and reassurance that future decisions will be handled with greater consistency and respect for demonstrated community support.
Have a view on this?
If you'd like to share your perspective — or point me to information I should look at — the best way is to send me a message.
Contact Shane →